The Violence Pendulum
Tactical Change in Islamist Groups in Egypt and Indonesia
Ioana Emy Matesan
Reviews and Awards
"Emy Matesan's analysis of repression in Egypt and Indonesia could not be more timely given the increasing use of violence against civilians around the world by authoritarian governments. Explaining the connection between government repression limiting options for nonviolent tactics, she shows how they reinforce mistrust in the government and foster a desire for revenge. This groundbreaking study shows how groups move along the spectrum from radicalization and engaging in violence to disengagement and non-violent forms of resistance. Assessing the efficacy of these various tactics and highlighting the inherent pragmatism of even the most ideological leaders, Matesan's work is destined to be a classic in the study of violence and peaceful resistance." -- Mia Bloom , Professor of Communication and Middle East Studies, Georgia State University, and author of Small Arms: Children and Terrorism
"A much-needed comparative analysis of how and why Islamist opposition groups shift between escalation and de-escalation, as their tactics evolve over time. The explanation expertly weaves together different causal threads to stress the importance of timing, the multiple pathways to violence and non-violence, and the relationship between principles and pragmatism in guiding the behavior of extremist groups. The book also serves as an important caution against reliance on repression to combat terrorism." -- Martha Crenshaw , Senior Fellow Emerita, Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies, Stanford University and Professor Emerita of Government, Wesleyan University
"This carefully researched and richly detailed study explores the answers to one of the most vexing questions about extremist movements — why do they choose violence, and why do they abandon it? Taking the internal perspective of movements in Egypt and Indonesia, this book shows that these are strategic choices influenced by perceptions of opportunity and potential support. Its thoughtful insights into the pendulum of violence and nonviolence have global implications for understanding the dynamics of extremist movements around the world." -- Mark Juergensmeyer , Professor of Global Studies, University of California, Santa Barbara, and author of Terror in the Mind of God: The Global Rise of Religious Violence