Reviews and Awards
Named an Outstanding Academic Book for 1995 by Choice
"A very important undertaking, representing the first English-language effort to examine comprehensively the development of Jewish musical life in Palestine....An easily read, remarkably interesting, and very important synthesis."--Choice
"A study that will grip anyone interested in attending the birth of a national art. What emerges from his story...is the urgency of Jewish need for organized music in an unbuilt land. The people's passion makes long stretches of this social history simply irresistible."--Jewish Chronicle
"Hirshberg has produced an exceptionally vivid record of a remarkable cultural achievement in an era of momentous consequence...an informative and readable volume by a thorough and critical 'insider,' bolstered by extensive and varied documentation."--Middle East Journal
"...an enriching approach....it adds an important aspect to our understanding of social Jewish history and the history of music."--Religious Studies Review