Moths, Myths, and Mosquitoes

The Eccentric Life of Harrison G. Dyar, Jr.

Marc Epstein

A compelling narrative that details both Dyar's illustrious scientific career and his complex personal life
A well-researched biography of a fascinating yet little-known American scientist
A new look at the man who revolutionized insect classification

Moths, Myths, and Mosquitoes

The Eccentric Life of Harrison G. Dyar, Jr.

Marc Epstein

Description

On September 26, 1924, the ground collapsed beneath a truck in a back alley in Washington, D.C., revealing a mysterious underground labyrinth. In spite of wild speculations, the tunnel was not the work of German spies, but rather an aging, eccentric Smithsonian scientist named Harrison Gray Dyar, Jr. While Dyar's covert tunneling habits may seem far-fetched, they were merely one of many oddities in Dyar's unbelievable life.

For the first time, insect biosystematist Marc E. Epstein presents a complete account of Dyar's life story. Dyar, one of the most influential biologists of the twentieth century, focused his entomological career on building natural classifications of various groups of insects. His revolutionary approach to taxonomy, which examined both larval and adult stages of insects, brought about major changes in the scientific community's understanding of natural relationships and insect systematics. He was also the father of what came to be known as Dyar's Law, a pragmatic method to standardize information on insect larval stages as they grow. Over the course of his illustrious career at the U.S. National Museum, Smithsonian Institution from 1897-1929, Dyar named over 3,000 species, established the "List of North American Lepidoptera," an unrivaled catalog of moths and butterflies, and built one of the nation's premier lepidoptera and mosquito collections.

However, Dyar's scientific accomplishments are a mere component of this remarkable biography. Epstein offers an account of Dyar's complicated personal life, from his feuds with fellow entomologists to the scandalous revelation that he was married to two wives at the same time. Epstein also chronicles Dyar's exploration of the Baha'i faith, his extensive travels, his innumerable works of unpublished fiction, and the loss of his wealth from bad investments. Comprehensive and engaging, Moths, Myths, and Mosquitoes will delight entomologists and historians alike, as well as anyone interested in exploring the zany life of one of America's virtually unknown scientific geniuses.

Moths, Myths, and Mosquitoes

The Eccentric Life of Harrison G. Dyar, Jr.

Marc Epstein

PART I: PREPARATORY STAGES

Ch. 1: The Dyars and the Hannums: An Earlier Generation

Ch. 2: Dyar, Jr: Early Growth Stages and Development

Ch. 3: Collecting and Rearing Lepidoptera, and Dyar's Law: 1882-1891

Ch. 4: Long Collecting Trips and Sawflies: 1889-1897

Ch. 5: Postgraduate Education: Classification of Moths and Bacteria

Ch. 6: Genealogy of the Limacodidae and the Dyars

Ch. 7: Last Days in New York, L.O. Howard, and a Move to the U.S. National Museum

PART II: BEGINNING A NEW LIFE AT THE USNM AND IN WASHINGTON

Ch. 8: Life in the District of Columbia and Wellesca Pollock

Ch. 9: Building the National Collection, Dyar's "List of Lepidoptera," and the Entomological Society of Washington

Ch. 10: Battle of the Titans Smith and Dyar, and Their New Love - The "Skeets"

Ch. 11: Collecting Moths, Mosquitoes, and Travels: 1901-1909

Ch. 12: Literature Wars and Last Battles with Smith

Ch. 13: Advances and Conflicts in Professional Life as a Lepidopterist: 1907-1914

PART III: MRS. ALLEN, DIVORCES, AND THE AFTERMATH OF THE
SCANDAL

Ch. 14: Wellesca's Baha'i Faith, New Wealth and Growing Concerns by Zella as Dyar's Life Begins to Unravel: 1906-1908

Ch. 15: Marriage Troubles

Ch. 16: The Separation: 1915

Ch. 17: Divorce Wranglings in Reno

Ch. 18: Divorces, Appeals, and Bigamy

Ch. 19: After the Scandal, Dismissal, and Friend Knab: 1917-1918

PART IV: THE FINAL DECADE: ATTEMPTS AT REINSTATEMENT

Ch. 20: The National Collection of Lepidoptera, its Workers, and Their Tiffs: 1920s

Ch. 21: Mosquitoes and Pursuit of Reinstatement

Ch. 22: Dyar and His Tunnels

Ch. 23: Personal Life and Baha'is in the 1920s

Ch. 24: Unity in the UNSM Lepidoptera Section and Acquiring the Barnes Collection

Ch. 25: Final Days: Trip West, Projects, and as Custodian

Ch. 26: Financial Collapse and Final Push for Reinstatement

Epilogue

Moths, Myths, and Mosquitoes

The Eccentric Life of Harrison G. Dyar, Jr.

Marc Epstein

Author Information

Marc E. Epstein is Senior Insect Biosystematist for Lepidoptera at the California Department of Food and Agriculture and Research Associate at the National Museum of Natural History (NMNH), Smithsonian Institution. He researches and writes on evolution and classification of moths and their biodiversity, and develops identification tools for moths that threaten agriculture. At the NMNH he was in the Department of Entomology (1988-2003), cofounding the Department's Archives and Illustration Archives. His research on caterpillars, including images and videos, is currently featured in the NMNH exhibit "More than Meets the Eye" and has been a guest on NPR's "Fresh Air" about his work on the book "Night Visions: the Secret Design of Moths." Dr. Epstein's published work includes a Smithsonian monograph on limacodid moths and the article "Digging for Dyar: the man behind the myth" with Pamela M. Henson. Degrees: Ph.D. and M.S., Entomology, University of Minnesota -1988 and 1982, B.S., Entomology and Zoology, Colorado State University, 1977.

Moths, Myths, and Mosquitoes

The Eccentric Life of Harrison G. Dyar, Jr.

Marc Epstein

Reviews and Awards

"Historians of science - especially those interested in the development of natural history, systematics, and museums - and anyone drawn to scientific biography will find much that is appealing in this accessible and engaging volume." -- Mark V. Barrow, Jr., Isis Journal

"To write Moths, Myths, and Mosquitoes, Epstein dug deep into the Smithsonian's holdings of publications, correspondence, diaries, unpublished short stories and novellas, newspaper articles and marriage certificates, providing rich context for Dyar's intellectual and scientific milieu. Epstein's descriptions of Dyar's collecting trips and battles with colleagues are particularly evocative." --Nature

"[A] fascinating biography and valuable scientific account of entomologist Harrison Dyar Jr. ... This entertaining, well-researched volume includes numerous photos (some previously unpublished). Recommended." --CHOICE

"H. G. Dyar, Jr., was not your average entomologist in accomplishment, demeanor, or eccentricity. But he was indeed a fascinating character, and Epstein's book comprehensively describes his interesting life." --American Entemologist

"Epstein's writing is clear and enthralling, drawing the reader from one surreal event in Dyar's life to another... The acknowledgements are extensive, showing the level of research and scholarship that went into the book's production...I highly recommend this book... If you are looking for a biography that puts reality television to shame, search no further." --News of The Lepidopterists' Society

"Combining the professional publications with personal and public resources, the author reveals a depth not only to Dyar's personality but to the entire field of entomology in the latter half of the 19th century. ...Epstein successfully weaves together the personal, professional, and quirky dimensions of Dyar's life providing readers with a more complete context for understanding his contributions." --THE QUARTERLY REVIEW OF BIOLOGY

"[This] book is as informative as it is entertaining. Once I started reading...I was seized with an undeniable fancy to keep going." -- Martin J. Andree, Newsletter of the Michigan Entomological Society

Moths, Myths, and Mosquitoes

The Eccentric Life of Harrison G. Dyar, Jr.

Marc Epstein

From Our Blog

A Flame as a Moth: How I began chronicling the life of Harrison G. Dyar, Jr., Part 2

I joined the staff in the Smithsonian's Department of Entomology, National Museum of Natural History in 1992, at the time Pam Henson and I published 'Digging for Dyar: The Man Behind the Myth'. Having stayed in Washington, DC long enough to complete the article, my job at the Museum would give me roughly a dozen years to accumulate information on Dyar, while performing other duties.

Posted on August 27, 2016

Read the blog post

A flame as a moth: how I began chronicling the life of Harrison G. Dyar, Jr., Part 1

I first became acquainted with Dyar's work on the moth family Limacodidae, my chosen entomology dissertation topic, in 1983 at the University of Minnesota. It was in the Hodson Hall library on the St. Paul campus where I noted how Dyar's authorship dominated the Journal of the New York Entomological Society in the middle to late 1890s. Particularly notable was his running series from 1895-1899

Posted on August 24, 2016

Read the blog post