Missionaries of Republicanism
A Religious History of the Mexican-American War
John C. Pinheiro
Reviews and Awards
Winner of the Fr. Paul J. Foik Award from the Texas Catholic Historical Society
"This book is essential reading for students of the Mexican War as well as American political culture. Pinheiro is especially strong in documenting how Protestant Anglo-Saxonism shaped political discourse throughout the conflict but also conditioned military decisions and the wartime experiences of countless Protestant and Catholic soldiers. Although scholars have long recognized the influence of anti-Catholicism in antebellum society, Pinheiro convincingly demonstrates that anti-Catholic Anglo-Saxonism sparked militant nativism long before the late nineteenth century." --James R. Rohrer, Fides et Historia
"John C. Pinheiro provides an elegant and concise overview of the growth of American anti-Catholicism in the 1830s and 1840s ...The most compelling consideration yet of the power of anti-Catholic discourse on the U.S. side of the conflict."--Journal of American History
"John C. Pinheiro has opened the door to a fresh, but convincing, understanding of the events and ideological milieu that led to the Mexican War. " --First Things
"For those interested in the interplay of politics and religion within the context of American history, Pinheiro's book sets a new standard for sophistication of analysis. His point is not to engage in reviving and refighting sectarian battles but rather to bring to light and contextualize religion's influence, for better and worse, upon the formation of American political culture. The fact that he writes in an accessible way, but without over-simplifying matters, means that the audience for this book goes far beyond the academy. For anyone interested in the religious history of the United States and the way this has impacted America's relations with its neighbors, this book would be a welcome addition to their library."--Religion and Liberty
"Pinheiro demonstrates persuasively how anti-Catholicism informed arguments both for and against the Mexican-American War, and how its rhetoric and logic permeated Protestant and Catholic Americans experiences of the War, from policy-makers to foot soldiers." --Religion in American History
"Pinheiro effectively incorporates religion into the American worldview during the Mexican American war. Oftentimes, historians fail to acknowledge the the central importance of religion in shaping United States history, but Pinheiro successfully gives his readers a more holistic understanding." --Daily History
"In a time when so much political attention is focused on questions of religious liberty, the brutal honesty of Missionaries [of Republicanism] is a breath of fresh air." --Ethika Politika
"Focusing on the widespread anti-Catholicism that shaped much of American culture in the 1840s, Pinheiro has written an unusual, provocative, and important analysis of the nation's creed and how it was shaped by the unfolding war with Mexico. This book is a groundbreaking achievement." --Joel H. Silbey, author of Party Over Section: The Rough and Ready Presidential Election of 1848
"For too long, American religious historians avoided war. We wrote about origins and outcomes, but rarely the conflicts themselves. This has changed recently, and John Pinheiro so elevates the discussion with Missionaries of Republicanism that the field may never be the same. With elegant prose and clear arguments, Pinheiro shows how anti-Catholicism became the unifying thread that tied together white American Protestants in their approaches to and experiences of the Mexican-American War. Even more, Pinheiro uncovers how anti-Catholic republican Protestantism became the primary way Americans understood the West and the nation writ large. This is a book for all students of American religions and American wars." --Edward J. Blum, author of Reforging the White Republic: Race, Religion, and American Nationalism, 1865-1898
"In this much-needed history, John Pinheiro vividly illuminates the interplay between race, religion, and politics during the Mexican War. Missionaries of Republicanism is essential reading for understanding the mindset of antebellum America." --Thomas S. Kidd, Professor of History, Baylor University
"Missionaries of Republicanism is well written and extensively researched. It stands as a fresh and provocative interpretation of the religious dimension of the Mexican-American war and the formation of a national identity that depended significantly upon a cultural anti-Catholicism. Students and scholars of American history should find this study stimulating and an important contribution to our understanding of how religion contributed to historical events and functioned as an interpretive lens of those events." --The University Bookman
"...Missionaries of Republicanism is valuable for showing how a politicized, racialized, and nationalistic religion emerged to surmount older theological and ecclesiastical divisions." --Journal of the Early Republic