Law as a Moral Idea

Nigel Simmonds

Advocates an ambitious original argument, connecting the nature of law directly with the form of freedom that distinguishes the slave from the free man
Provides an original critique of legal positivism, arguing that legal theory should reconnect with older and broader traditions of philosophical thinking about law
Explains the key philosophical debates surrounding law in a clear language that requires no previous expertise or study of philosophy

Law as a Moral Idea

Nigel Simmonds

Description

This book argues that the institutions of law, and the structures of legal thought, are to be understood by reference to a moral ideal. The idea of law is an ideal of freedom, or independence from the power of others. The moral value and justificatory force of law are not contingent upon circumstance, but intrinsic to its character as law. Doctrinal legal arguments are shaped by rival conceptions of the conditions for realisation of the idea of law.

In making these claims, the author rejects the viewpoint of much contemporary legal theory, and seeks to move jurisprudence closer to an older tradition of philosophical reflection upon law, exemplified by Hobbes and Kant. Modern analytical jurisprudence has tended to view these older philosophies as confused precisely in so far as they equate an understanding of law's nature with a revelation of its moral basis. According to most contemporary legal theorists, the understanding and analysis of existing institutions is quite distinct from any enterprise of moral reflection. But the relationship between ideals and practices is much more intimate than this approach would suggest. Some institutions can be properly understood only when they are viewed as imperfect attempts to realise moral or political ideals; and some ideals can be conceived only by reference to their expression in institutions.

Law as a Moral Idea

Nigel Simmonds

Law as a Moral Idea

Nigel Simmonds

Author Information

Nigel Simmonds, Reader in Jurisprudence, University of Cambridge

Law as a Moral Idea

Nigel Simmonds

Reviews and Awards

"This is a deep-going and deeply considered work, which should have a civilizing and reformative influence on English-speaking legal philosophy." - John Finnis

"Beautifully written and consistently illuminating." - John Gardner

"Law as a Moral Idea contains an important and original theory of the nature of law by a profound and brilliant thinker. It deserves to be read and carefully pondered by anyone seeking to gain a greater understanding of law in the modern world." - Sean Coyle, Journal of Moral Philosophy

"The seriousness by which Simmonds addresses the central claims of...positivists, often in forensic detail, is one of the strongest features of this book. He never attacks a straw-man and he clearly criticises the claims of his opponents on their home turf...A superb work in legal philosophy." - Patrick Capps, (2008) 28 Legal Studies 631-633

"The arguments are precise and subtle. I highly recommend ...this book, which is an invaluable contribution to our reflections on law and justice." - Professor Cristobal Orrego, Persona y Derecho

"For a clear and elegantly argued ... view of law that balances the mundane reality of legislation, precedent and practice against the ideal or aspirational quality of legality, one need look no further... I have never seen the case for this view more clearly and persuasively stated than it is in Law as a Moral Idea." - Sir Neil MacCormick

"A deep but accessible discussion that will prompt reflection and re-engagement with many of the most important and difficult problems of jurisprudence" - Mark Bennett, Canadian Bar Review