Dance in Chains
Political Imprisonment in the Modern World
Padraic Kenney
Reviews and Awards
"Dance in Chains provides a good start into the confrontation with the 'political prison' in the 20th century. Kenney's great achievement is to solve the issue of a specific case and the history of a single regime and to understand it as a superordinate phenomenon in the 20th century. The study invites to further thinking and critical questioning of a problem, which, as the author also shows, has not lost its relevance." -- Lucia Herrmann, H-Soz-Kult
"In his detailed and nuanced account, Kenney argues that the experience of imprisonment neither erases the identity of the prisoner nor dilutes the potent ideology that lands him or her in prison in the first place ... Ultimately, this is a story of how both liberal and totalitarian empires crumbled in the twentieth century in the face of determined opponents. By putting both kinds of political formations within the same analytical frame, Kenney has performed an invaluable service for our field ... A significant book that will spark conversations, stir up historiographical controversies, and hopefully make us re-think the way that we practice history in our field." -- Choi Chatterjee, Slavic Review
"Dance in Chains provides a good start into the confrontation with the 'political prison' in the 20th century. Kenney's great achievement is to solve the issue of a specific case and the history of a single regime and to understand it as a superordinate phenomenon in the 20th century. The study invites to further thinking and critical questioning of a problem, which, as the author also shows, has not lost its relevance."--Lucia Herrmann, H-Soz-Kult
"The concept of a political prisoner is important for all movements that oppose or wish to bring down dictatorships and oppressive systems. Every political prisoner is at times an object of respect and disdain; he is both esteemed and stigmatized. Solzhenitsyn wrote that prison saved him from the disgrace of collaborating with a totalitarian regime. That may well be, but we should not wish anyone this way of saving his soul. Padraic Kenney's book describes the many ambiguities of being a political prisoner and of being perceived as one. It is sure to invite impassioned responses from past, present, and future political prisoners."--Adam Michnik, Editor-in-Chief, Gazeta Wyborcza
"Modernity may have been emancipatory but, as Padraic Kenney shows in this fascinating and wide-ranging study, it also gave birth to a new kind of 'political' imprisonment. Taking the reader inside the prison and vividly documenting both the instances of repression and spaces for maneuver that the experience of incarceration involves, Kenney has produced one of the most original studies of modern politics in years. From Eastern Europe to South Africa and from Irish rebels to contemporary terrorists, Dance in Chains also shows how to connect globe-spanning world history with finely textured social history. A triumph."--Samuel Moyn, author of The Last Utopia: Human Rights in History
"Extremely informative, comprehensive, detailed, and extremely well-written. In the contemporary world of inter- and intra-state conflicts, imprisonment, torture, and the new state language of 'extraordinary rendition' (read kidnap and abduction) which seeks to obscure what is really happening on the ground, it is all the more important that we understand how the political prisoner has been defined/redefined and, most importantly, treated and mistreated over time. This book will be of immense value to the scholar of prison studies but equally to the lay person who seeks to find some understanding of how and why political imprisonment evolved over the past century and more and how, unfortunately, it will remain with us for some time to come."--Laurence McKeown, author of Out of Time: Irish Republican Prisoners Long Kesh, 1972 -2000
"If Foucault's Discipline and Punish described how disciplinary consciousness appeared in early 19th century Europe, Kenney's Dance in Chains describes how a new subjectivity as a political prisoner emerged as a global phenomenon in the 20th century. Political prisoners defined their subjectivity not by protesting the prison but by using it to shape themselves into new political agents. Kenney has written a critical genealogy against which we can understand how being a political prisoner exploded into popular consciousness and human rights discourse, and even how incarceration came to be, for many, a prerequisite for political activity itself."--Darius Rejali, author of Torture and Democracy
"Study of the phenomenon of political imprisonment, a favorite ploy of authoritarians throughout history...A provocative, well-argued view of practices mostly abandoned by the nations of the world save for a few-the U.S. notable among them."--Kirkus Reviews