Containing Balkan Nationalism
Imperial Russia and Ottoman Christians, 1856-1914
Denis Vovchenko
Reviews and Awards
"In Containing Balkan Nationalism, Denis Vovchenko makes an important contribution to the understanding and explication of the circumstances and consequences of the Bulgarian quest to create an autonomous Bulgarian Orthodox Church in the late nineteenth century."--Gregory Bruess, Slavic Review
"The book is a wonderful corrective to current historiographical understandings of Russia's role in the Balkans in the twilight of the Ottoman Empire. Vovchenko uses an astonishing array of Russian Imperial, Ottoman, Bulgarian, Greek, and Serbian archives Overall, the book is a useful addition to anyone putting together a reading list on nineteenth-century Balkan nationalism, or as Vovchenko himself suggests, those interested in supranational identity building, such as those forging (salvaging) a common European identity. "--Dan Gashler, H-Net
"[T]he great value of Vovchenko s work is that it demonstrates that there is an alternative to ethnocentric political and religious institutions. In a time when ethnic identity politics still play a major role on the world scene, Vovchenko shows how promoting Pan-religious identities can be a viable alternative to deeper state fragmentation over ethnic differences. Within the realm of Christianity, Vovchenko also details how the Orthodox Church adapted itself to ethnic differences, yet remained committed to the notion that ultimately Christianity trumps ethnicity, a point in which the American Church divided by white, Korean, Hispanic, and other ethnocentric groupings would do well to heed."--Reading Religion
"Vovchenko's timely and meticulously-researched new book highlights the centrality of religion for Eastern European national and supranational movements. He shows in fine mosaic how a localized movement for religious autonomy engaged Russian and Ottoman policy-makers in complex diplomacy at the highest levels. A fresh and valuable resource for scholars interested in the former Russian-Ottoman space, the book can also help us understand religious dimensions of the current conflict in Ukraine." --Mara Kozelsky, Associate Professor of History, University of South Alabama
"In this intriguing book based on sources in multiple languages, Denis Vovchenko delves directly into one of the most complex questions of nineteenth-century politics-the relationship between religion and politicized ethnicity. His investigation reveals striking tensions between the principle of Orthodox unity and the process of ethnic fragmentation in Balkan ecclesiastical politics in the decades after the Crimean War. Vovchenko insists on the stubborn persistence of religious and dynastic conceptions for the major players in Bulgarian church affairs and thus offers a compelling challenge to teleological narratives of modern nationalism. Remarkable for its attention to the multiple perspectives that informed this complicated story, Containing Balkan Nationalism provides valuable insights on Russian, Ottoman, and Balkan history." --Paul W. Werth, Professor and Chair, Department of History, University of Nevada, Las Vegas
"In this widely researched and highly original account, Denis Vovchenko reveals how Eastern Orthodox Christians worked together across borders to challenge and blunt nationalism in the Balkans. Scholars of Russian, Balkan, and Ottoman history and of international relations more generally will find Vovchenko's research informative and his perspective fresh and stimulating." --Michael A. Reynolds, Associate Professor of Near Eastern Studies, Princeton University
