Beyond Melancholy
Sadness and Selfhood in Renaissance England
Erin Sullivan
Reviews and Awards
"Sullivan's sustained examination of the 'more personal and practical manifestations' of sadness are refreshingly sensitive to, and engagingly positive about, the easily obscured felt experience of a historically specific but 'messy' emotion." -- Eric Langley, The Seventeenth Century.
"It is a very intelligent and thoughtful book which produces a fascinating range of examples, including the number of deaths recorded from grief, the proportion of men who suffered from melancholy as opposed to women, and the various symptoms associated with 'melancholy, including light-headedness, heart problems and urinary problems. Even among these gripping testimonies to feeling, however, the construction of sadness remains somewhat illusive: Sullivan gestures towards the complexities inherent in evaluating or even defining such a subjective, yet social, emotion but we never really get any closer to what sadness might mean and how it is identified as such across the literature." --Charlotte Scott, Shakespeare Studies
"Erin Sullivan's Beyond Melancholy offers ample proof of how much there is still to be gained from an in-depth, meticulously contextualized study of an emotion. Marshalling an impressive array of sources...Beyond Melancholy offers a powerfully synthesizing approach which is nevertheless careful to respect the multi-faceted, contested and often seemingly contradictory ways in which sadness was experienced, viewed by different interpretative communities, and represented."--Freya Sierhuis, Shakespeare Jahrbuch
"[A] fine first book...Sullivan's very readable study draws on sources as diverse as moral treatises, mortality records, devotional poetry, letters and ballads."--Karen Shook, Times Higher Education
"[B]rilliant...Sullivan's masterstroke is to show that the world of letters and of drama unlocks the history of experience, connecting discursive debates about conceptual incommensurabilities to a lived reality in which the meaning of embodied and spiritual feelings were sought."--Rob Boddice, Contributions to the History of Concepts
"[A]n elegant study...This book is significant for complicating our understanding of sadness to encompass not only the corporeal and medical but also the religious, philosophical and immaterial...Beyond Melancholy shows the value of literary texts and methods to the history of emotions and to the history of medicine more broadly."--Olivia Weisser, Medical History
"Erin Sullivan's scholarly and consistently engaging contribution to OUP's Emotions in History series, Beyond Melancholy, sets out not only to add nuance, local complexity, and taxonomic specificity to broad period conceptions of sadness, but also to make sadness less depressing, showing how depictions of this temperamental excess may be pervasive but not exclusively negative...Sullivan has recourse to an impressive array of period texts and sources, often devoting considerable time to detailed, and often suitably graphic, accounts of medical practice and case-records, full of scurvy, flatulence, cramps, and fluids. This study, quite intentionally and to its credit, is as comfortable with medical history as cultural history...There is a real wealth of material here for future scholars..."--Eric Langley, The Seventeenth Century
"Erin Sullivan's remarkably wide-ranging new book achieves a level of scholarly balance that would secure the approval of any discerning Renaissance physician. In it, she sifts a large and diverse range of historical sources to offer colour and nuance to many 'emotionologies' (conventions) of sadness, recent and contemporary, and their relationships with differing and dominant conceptions of self, body, mind and soul."--Charles Green, Birmingham Journal of Language and Literature
"This book has helped me further appreciate the complexity of human emotions and has shown me the relevance of an unfamiliar period of history to my daily clinical practice."--Tom Russ, The British Journal of Psychiatry