Apt Imaginings

Feelings for Fictions and Other Creatures of the Mind

Jonathan Gilmore

Thinking Art

Draws on a wealth of empirical research in the psychology and neuroscience of the imagination
Introduces a unified explanation of both reality-direct attitudes and feelings and those elicited by fictional works of art
Offers an interdisciplinary account, one that draws on philosophy of art, psychology and neuroscience, moral philosophy, the history of philosophy, and literary theory

Apt Imaginings

Feelings for Fictions and Other Creatures of the Mind

Jonathan Gilmore

Description

How do our engagements with fictions and other products of the imagination compare to our experiences of the real world? Are the feelings we have about a novel's characters modelled on our thoughts about actual people? If it is wrong to feel pleasure over certain situations in real life, can it nonetheless be right to take pleasure in analogous scenarios represented in a fantasy or film? Should the desires we have for what goes on in a make-believe story cohere with what we want to happen in the actual world? Such queries have animated philosophical and psychological theorizing about art and life from Plato's Republic and Aristotle's Poetics to contemporary debates over freedom of expression, ethics and aesthetics, the cognitive value of thought experiments, and the effects on audiences of exposure to violent entertainment.

In Apt Imaginings, Jonathan Gilmore develops a new framework to pursue these questions, marshalling a wide range of research in aesthetics, the science of the emotions, moral philosophy, neuroscience, cognitive psychology, and film and literary theory. Gilmore argues that, while there is a substantial empirical continuity in our feelings across art and life, the norms that govern the appropriateness of those responses across the divide are discontinuous. In this view, the evaluative criteria that determine the fit, correctness, or rationality of our emotions and desires for what is internal to a fiction can be contrary to those that govern our affective attitudes toward analogous things in the real world. In short, it can be right to embrace within a story what one would condemn in real life. The theory Gilmore defends in this volume helps to explain our complex and sometimes conflicted attitudes toward works of the imagination; challenges the popular view that fictions serve to refine our moral sensibilities; and exposes a kind of autonomy of the imagination that can render our responses to art immune to standard real-world epistemic, practical, and affective kinds of criticism.

Apt Imaginings

Feelings for Fictions and Other Creatures of the Mind

Jonathan Gilmore

Thinking Art

Acknowledgements

Chapter One: Introduction
Chapter Two: The Cognitive Imagination and Literary Fiction
Chapter Three: Evaluative Emotions
Chapter Four: Apt Emotions and Normative Continuity
Chapter Five: Defending Discontinuity
Chapter Six: Epistemology of Fiction and Rational Imagining
Chapter Seven: Tragedy and Desire
Chapter Eight: Discrepant Affects
Chapter Nine: Artistic Functions

Index
Bibliography

Apt Imaginings

Feelings for Fictions and Other Creatures of the Mind

Jonathan Gilmore

Thinking Art

Author Information

Jonathan Gilmore is a philosopher of art and art critic. He is Associate Professor of Philosophy at the CUNY Graduate Center and Baruch College. Prior to arriving at CUNY, he was Assistant Professor of Philosophy and Humanities at Yale University, and a Cotsen Postdoctoral Fellow in the Society of Fellows at Princeton University. A 2013-2014 National Endowment for the Humanities Fellow, he has published widely on the emotions, the imagination, philosophy of literature, philosophy of art history, freedom of expression, and twentieth-century European philosophy. His art criticism has appeared in such venues as Artforum, Art in America, ArtNews, Tema Celeste, Modern Painters, and several exhibition catalogues.

Apt Imaginings

Feelings for Fictions and Other Creatures of the Mind

Jonathan Gilmore

Thinking Art

Reviews and Awards

Winner of the American Society for Aesthetics Outstanding Monograph Prize for 2021

"A fascinating and invigorating book that shows the bonds between philosophy, psychology and cognitive sciences at their best... Not only does Gilmore's book reveal much about our everyday cognitive and emotional processes, thus enabling us to better understand our reactions toward non- fictional entities, it has the capacity to address some of the most pressing questions regarding the cultural, educational, and ethical relevance of art and art-engagements" -- Philosophy in Review

"Gilmore raises a very interesting set of issues, and does so in a thoughtful way, so that we may imagine possibilities for understanding human character." -- Keith Oatley, Evolutionary Studies in Imaginative Culture

"What you really want to know is, should you read this book? Yes, of course you should...The book is rewarding and engaging." -- Nicholas Wiltsher, The European Journal of Aesthetics

"Jonathan Gilmore's new book, Apt Imaginings: Feelings for Fictions and Other Creatures of the Mind, is a treat: it is bold, compelling, and carefully argued. It makes important contributions to a variety of different debates in and around the philosophy of art, including the status of imagined or quasi-emotions, the (so-called) paradox of tragedy, the debate over artistic functions, and the problem of moral and aesthetic interaction. It is beautifully written, filled with vivid and apt examples from the arts and thoughtful application of results from the sciences." -- James Harold, The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism