All Is Well
Catastrophe and the Making of the Normal State
Saptarishi Bandopadhyay
Reviews and Awards
"Bandopadhyay (York Univ., Canada) compellingly argues that nation-states use natural disasters as a means of legitimizing authority. He contends that disasters do not exist outside a government structure, and that causes and solutions to catastrophic events are inexorably intertwined." -- C. A. Sproles, CHOICE
"An ambitious and timely intervention into a pressing set of concerns, questions, and issues. By combining a longue durée approach with a focus on writing a 'history of the present', Bandopadhyay produces original insights of cross-cultural significance. Those insights will have application to the numerous projects which will surely emerge to rebuild states, societies, economies, and systems in the wake of the current pandemic." -- Sundhya Pahuja, Director of the Institute for International Law and the Humanities, Melbourne Law School
"A thought-provoking and somewhat audacious book that challenges our notions about the very foundations of state power and its historic role in disaster management. Far from saving people from nature's fury, Bandopadhyay argues that disasters provide a way for state power to renew itself. Masterfully drawing on eighteenth century examples from France, Portugal, and India to support his case, the author admonishes us to look more closely at how the world around us is governed. A compelling read." -- Greg Bankoff, Professor Emeritus of Environmental History, University of Hull
"Ironically titled, All Is Well provides a wide-ranging, timely critique of the world of disasters. Bandopadhyay acknowledges earthquakes, floods, and plagues are real and horrific enough. However, he shows 'disasters' to be socially constructed, mainly through official discourses that serve state power. He also finds such awareness largely absent from mainstream disaster work, where the primacy of 'the government' and 'the international community' is rarely questioned. In our own time, these hegemonic strategies are shown to support liberal, international, and ecological initiatives. In the face of existential insecurity and frightful losses, they are seen to 'normalize' gross economic and social disparities, and ecological destruction." -- Kenneth Hewitt, , Professor Emeritus of Geography and Environmental Studies, Wilfrid Laurier University